Hello!These shoes are straight-up adorable, no question. And they seemed like they would be comfortable.But, they had a scent about them that I was unable to get past. As much as I didn't want to, I had to return them. Thank youI've been looking for a more grownup version of the cotton Mary Janes I used to get from Chinatown for years and these are just perfect for me! I do have narrow, skinny feet and these definitely do not flop around on my feet - i just needed a little extra insole from heel to midfoot. If you have wide or fat feet you might not like these.The style is fantastic - the lower band really lets your ankles shine on their own, and doesn't appear to "cut off" the leg, visually. They also make my size 10 feet look absolutely dainty, and I love them for it! I was hesitant to pay so much for PU but I just bought the pink ones too... Love them!They fit, but it's a little tight at my toes. For reference, I ordered the size 11. They won't kill my feet, but I'm going to have to break them in.Liked the comfort and the price. The fit a little off too large but manageable. Overall I like the shoeI am slowly buying every color, I love these shoes! They are super comfy with a softer material, not hard and uncomfortable.I think I know why people are having a hard time with sizes! I sized up on the first pair, I purchased Black in size 10. They fit perfectly! When I purchased the Red in a size 10 they were too big. Exchanging them was very simple, customer service is great. I ordered the size 9 and they fit perfectly.So, there does appear to be size differences in colors. Keep in mind you might need to exchange once and you will be happy after!These are the Red in size 9. The website color is accurate they are cherry red!I walk a lot and these are super comfy! Very cute shoes! I Highly recommend!I really wish that these shoes had half sizes, I normally wear a size 8, but the 8s for these shoes was entirely too tight. It fit more like a 7 or 7.5. especially when you put the heel pads in which were needed because these shoes cut up my heels BAD, but then the pads mad the shoes that much smaller.All that being said, I ended up ordering a pair of 9s and they were pretty lose, but putting the heel pads in and adjusting the straps made the shoes fit comfortably. They're really cute and nice shoes. I just wish that the sizing wasn't so off so that I didn't have to go through the hassle of making a return and re orderI am an adult who LOVES Mary Jane shoes. These are adorable and comfy. They even come with a pad to stick in your shoe to help with heel rubs.Ordered these shoes for my granddaughter's upcoming wedding. Very nice style and quality, but they definitely run small. Had to reorder larger size. Wish they came in half sizes.